Dating apps have changed how a lot of people meet. They’ve also given us a very recognisable habit.

Someone matches with a great person. They’re funny, they’re kind, they want the same things. The first date goes brilliantly. And yet, on the way home, their thumb drifts back to the app. What if there’s someone even better out there?

It’s a familiar story whether from friends, TV or the endless articles about modern dating. And lately, I’ve noticed the same feeling creeping into hiring.

The swipe left mentality

It goes something like this. We share a shortlist of the strongest people we’ve spoken with. They tick almost every box, on both the technical side and the personal side. Everyone’s had a good chat.

Then comes the gentle nudge: “These are great… but could you just keep looking?” “Is there anyone else out there?” “Can we see a couple more?”

It’s a bit like going on a lovely first date and reinstalling the app on the way home. Nothing has gone wrong. It’s just that little voice saying the perfect one might be one more swipe away.

Why it happens (and why it’s completely human)

Let’s be clear: this isn’t about anyone doing anything wrong. Hiring is a big decision. Budgets are tight, teams are stretched and nobody wants to get it wrong. Wanting to feel sure is natural.

And when you’re used to endless choice everywhere else in life, from what to watch to where to eat, it’s easy to assume there’s always another option just around the corner.

But the market doesn’t always work like that. You don’t get the pick of everyone out there. Plenty of brilliant people are happy where they are, and others simply don’t want to move. It’s a bit like assuming everyone at the party is single.

When your recruiter shares what they’re seeing (who’s available, at what level, at what salary), that’s come from the ground. Sometimes the person you met last week really is the best match out there. That’s not settling. That’s finding the one.

Candidates are dating too

Here’s the bit that’s easy to forget: great candidates have options. They’re talking to other businesses and they’ve often got more than one conversation on the go.

And just like in dating, everyone wants to feel wanted. When a process goes quiet or keeps stretching out, even the most enthusiastic candidate starts to wonder whether the feeling’s mutual. Not out of impatience, but because they want to join somewhere that’s genuinely excited about them.

Meanwhile, the role that could have been filled sits empty. The person who might have been three or six months in by now, settled and making a difference, has said yes somewhere else.

How to find your match (without endless swiping)

  • Know your must-haves before you start. Agree what “good” looks like up front and which things are deal-breakers versus nice-to-haves. It makes it much easier to spot the right person when they walk in.
  • Lean on your recruiter’s market view. We speak to people all day, every day. When we put someone forward, it’s because we genuinely believe they’re the best person for your role.
  • Don’t leave them on read. Quick feedback and clear next steps keep great candidates warm and keep the momentum going. Silence sends a message too and it’s rarely the one you mean. When no feedback comes, candidates read it as a clear sign you’re just not that into them.
  • Show some excitement. If someone feels right, let them know. Enthusiasm is one of the most underrated hiring tools there is.
  • Trust your gut. If they tick the boxes and the conversation flowed, that’s usually a very good sign.

Sometimes the one is already in front of you

The businesses landing the best people right now aren’t the ones seeing the most candidates. They’re the ones who know a great match when they see one, and say yes.

If you are currently hiring and would value a streamlined process, built on an honest partnership and clear market insight, I would be very happy to have a conversation.

Helena Ranger leads the Corporate & Brand Communications practice for the UK and US at Hanson Search, specialising in senior appointments across the full communications discipline.

Hanson Search Group is a global talent consultancy providing executive search, recruitment and leadership advisory services. Built on more than twenty years of trusted relationships, we operate as a connected global platform of specialist practices with expert consultants embedded in key markets.

Helena Ranger: Helena leads the Corporate & Brand Communications practice for the UK and US at Hanson Search, specialising in senior appointments across the full communications discipline: corporate and consumer PR, B2B, crisis communications, strategy and reputation, creative, brand, digital and influencer. Her remit spans both sides of the industry....

Related articles

  • Photography Wasn’t the Death of Painting and AI Won’t Be the Death of Art
  • Germany: 1 Country, 3 Markets
  • Can Someone Explain What’s Going on in the Hiring Market Right Now? 
  • Comebacks and Newcomers: What the 2026 Luxury Brand Rankings Reveal